Liner Comparison Chart

  HDPE
(High Density Polyethylene)
LLDPE
(Linear Low Density Polyethylene)
PVC
(Polyvinyl Chloride)
Advantages
  • Highest seam strength
  • Wide range of chemical resistance
  • Ultraviolet resistance
  • Can be patched with our geomembrane repair kit
  • High seam strength
  • More flexible than HDPE
  • Ultraviolet resistance
  • Can be patched with our geomembrane repair kit
  • High elasticity, conforms to subgrade irregularities
  • More flexible than HDPE and MDPE
  • Can be patched using adhesive and solvent
    Thicknesses 20, 30, 40, 60, 80, 100 mil 20, 30, 40, 60 mil 30, 40, 50, 60 mil
    Warranty Up to 20 years Up to 20 years Up to 20 years
    Disadvantages
  • No internal reinforcement mesh
  • Expands and contracts with temperature changes
  • No internal reinforcement mesh
  • Expands and contracts with temperature changes
  • Low seam strength
  • Not resistant to ultraviolet radiation
  • Becomes very brittle at low temperatures
  • Certain species of rodents are attracted to PVC
    Typical Uses
  • Secondary containment
  • Landfills
  • Lagoons
  • Ponds
  • Canals
  • Leach pads
  • Secondary containment
  • Ponds
  • Temporary covers
  • Landfill covers
  • Lagoons
  • Ponds
  • Landfill covers

     

      GCL
    (Geosynthetic Clay Liner)
    Ja-Guard Liner Fertoguard Liner
    (Reinforced Polypropylene)
    Advantages
  • Can take the place of a 2' layer of compacted clay
  • Installs quickly
  • Available in non-reinforced and reinforced
  • Flexible
  • Scrim reinforced
  • Fiber mesh reinforced for high tensile strength
  • More flexible than MDPE or HDPE
  • Can be repaired using hot air gun
  • Ultra-violet resistance
    Thicknesses -- 36 mil 36, 45 mil
    Warranty Up to 5 years Up to 20 years Up to 20 years
    Disadvantages
  • Must have at least 1' of cover soil to function properly
  • GCL is ruined if exposed to water before cover soil is placed
  • More expensive than PVC, HDPE, or MDPE
  • Breaks down in soils with high lime content
  • Higher in cost than HDPE or polypropylene
  • Exposed reinforcement mesh on edges must be encapsulated
  • Seams are not as strong as HDPE or MDPE seams
  • More expensive than MDPE or HDPE
    Typical Uses
  • Landfills
  • Lagoons
  • Ponds
  • Petroleum
  • Acids
  • Secondary containment
  • Small lagoons
  • Ponds